Regardless of how Scientology started, what it has become at the present is a total con job which promises potential converts a toolkit to solve the problems of their life and eventually a path to spiritual enlightenment and understanding. I say “con job” because over the past few years, it’s become more and more obvious to the world at large that Scientology is not everything it claims to be and it cannot fulfill any of the lofty promises it makes.
What’s even worse is that once someone joins its ranks, it is very hard to get out. For some who have broken away, they’ve found only pain and tragedy because Scientology has enforced its policy of disconnection on their friends and family, taking away their most precious loved ones simply because they exercised their right to think and act for themselves. Let’s not even talk about the really nasty stuff, when Scientology tries to publicly smear you and starts stalking and harassing you if you speak out against it.
With all the exposure in documentaries, the media and on channels such as this, we have certainly learned that Scientology is something to stay the hell away from. But have we learned anything else? Are there any other lessons we can take away from this which apply to the big wide world? You bet there are. Because the methods that Scientology uses to manipulate new recruits and existing members are not unique to Scientology. Not by a long way. And if we recognize that, we can learn to watch for some of them in other places and not get drawn into situations we don’t want to be in. Here are five harsh lessons I think we could all learn from Scientology:
(1) There’s no such thing as being too smart to fall for bullshit.
In living our lives, we tend to think of ourselves as the hero of our story, but let’s be honest, we often give ourselves far too much credit. If you take an honest assessment of times you have screwed up and why it happened, odds are you will find instances where you leaped before you looked or acted on an impulse which did not turn out to be a good one. Sometimes it’s hard for us to remember these because the way our minds work, we tend to forget those misses and only remember the hits, the times we made right decisions or chose the correct path.
We also tend to enjoy gloating or laughing at the mistakes of others. When it’s all in good fun or just comedy, then that’s fine. No harm, no foul. But when we tell ourselves that we are better than those people we are laughing at, when we think that we have never made stupid mistakes or that we couldn’t be fooled because we’re so smart – well, I’ll just tell you right now that when I was in Scientology it was those people I wanted to talk to first because they were the easiest marks.
In the best cons, the mark is not even aware he’s been scammed. The truth is that there is no one who can’t be deceived given the right ingredients. Even you. Maybe Scientology didn’t have the right mix to pull the wool over your eyes, but someone pulled a lottery ticket scam on you or one of many other cons like the mustard dip, the flop or the fake workmen. Just remember this: no one would be running the Nigerian prince scam if it didn’t work sometimes.
(2) Never ever give up the right to think for yourself.
Probably the most dangerous aspect of destructive cults is how their members give over the right to think for themselves. You’d think no one would willingly or knowingly do this and that’s the trick. Usually it’s done so smoothly that the person doesn’t realize it’s happening.
In Scientology, one of the methods used is to tell someone that if they don’t agree with something L. Ron Hubbard said or wrote, that it’s simply because they don’t understand it. Well, that could certainly be true in certain cases, but it could also be that Hubbard is simply wrong. Rather than admit to anything like that, Scientologists will spend literally hours plowing through dictionaries and encyclopedias trying to cure their lack of understanding of the words and phrases Hubbard uses to explain himself. It’s actually quite ridiculous and that’s the point. If you are being run through a series of hoops like that, you have to step back and say “Wait a minute. Is it okay if I simply disagree with this guy about this?” If the answer is “No, it’s not ok” than this is a group you should run, not walk, away from.
(3) Don’t excuse hypocrisy. It’s always a sign of corruption.
If you join a group and see the leaders are excused from the same rules as the ruled, you should have a problem with that. If the rules don’t apply to everyone, then they are really just ways for the leaders to control and take advantage of the members. In Scientology this occurs at many levels, especially within the Sea Organization where certain executives who toe the party line are given special advantages that others don’t get. Of course, those same executives could be scrubbing pots or sweeping floors the next day if they fall out of favor. The only one who consistently benefits from the money and power of Scientology is David Miscavige but Scientology is not alone in this kind of hypocrisy.
When corporations advertise themselves as caring and consumer-friendly but their store managers treat the employees like total crap, it’s hard to get behind their message. Employees of most retail outfits know this all too well.
As the late author Stephen Covey once said “What you do has far greater impact than what you say.” Rules and guidelines exist in groups to define what the groups values are, what is considered acceptable behavior and how the group should conduct itself. Whether it’s a work, play, sports or club environment, the rules should apply equally to everyone there.
(4) When you are making important decisions, park your ego.
This is related to the first point but deserves its own look.
We are emotion-driven creatures. We go with what feels good all the time over what we know we should be doing, whether it’s eating fast food, wasting time playing video games or having “just one more” before we leave the bar. Most of the time we get away with this and don’t think too much about it. What fun would any of this be if we didn’t do things we enjoy and which make us feel good?
However, when it comes to important decisions, being ruled by emotion often leaves us ignoring the facts and not thinking about the consequences. Advertisers, salesmen and con men know this about human nature and take advantage of it every single day.
Love bombing is a common tactic used to pump up our ego, showering us with praise or affection to get us to decide to go with whatever it is that we are being presented with. This is a blatant appeal to our emotions but it can come in so many different forms and usually feels so damn good that we sometimes don’t recognize it when it’s happening. In many cases, flattery will get people everywhere.
There’s a very easy way to tell if you are being put in a potentially compromising or dangerous position when someone is trying to convince you to do something. Simply tell them that you want to take some time to think about it, that you need to collect some more facts or talk it over with a friend or whatever. The degree that they try to stop you from doing that is a direct measure of how much they are trying to fool you. Because the truth is that there are very few big decisions you are ever going to have to make in life that require your immediate answer.
(5) Having special knowledge or secret wisdom does not make anyone better than anyone else.
Because we live in a somewhat dog-eat-dog world where it is advantageous for us to be better, faster, stronger or richer than people around us, our survival instincts tell us that it’s a good thing for us to gain any advantage we can. This includes gaining wisdom or knowledge that we think sets us above others, but this is actually just another ego trap, and one that cult leaders take special advantage of.
The way this works is someone claims to have special insight or knowledge which they are willing to share with only their chosen flock and that knowledge always comes for a price. This is not just religious knowledge. I’ve seen destructive cults of special knowledge involving politics, sales, medicine, martial arts and even acting. And the price members have to pay to gain this knowledge is not always just money. It also includes devotion or pledges of allegiance, unwarranted amounts of time and sacrificing interests in anything other than the group itself.
Here’s the thing: people who have gained real insight or wisdom are amongst the most humble and soft-spoken people you’ll ever meet and they are usually all to happy to share what they have learned for little or no price at all. Great intellectual leaders almost universally say that they are not smart and feel that they know hardly anything. We all know what braggarts and egotists look and sound like. While they may claim to be at the top of their field, they are actually the most insecure because they know they are not the best or brightest. So always take anyone who makes such claims with a grain of salt and don’t fall into the trap that thinking you’re something special just because you know some secret knowledge that no one else does. All it takes for you to not be so special is for them to learn it too and then where are you at?
What makes great people great is not what they know, it’s what they do with their knowledge.
Summary
I hope these tips can help extend our look beyond just Scientology and the nonsense it engages in with its members. It’s easy to watch and point fingers and think how stupid people must be to fall for such nonsense. Well, my advice is before doing that, take a good hard look at any nonsense you may be falling for yourself, because none of us are immune to it. If we can learn these lessons from Scientology and live better lives ourselves as a result, maybe it can do some good after all.
Thank you for watching.
So, traveling home on the last leg of a long journey, I strike up conversation with the guy alongside. He is a senior like me and when he asks what I’m doing nowadays, I say I’m retired now and I just want to write and carry on, try to make some contribution to the world in some artistic or creative way.
“What’s the book about?” , he asks, engaged. His name is Dave.
It is fiction, I tell him, based on me, my life which began growing up under the domain of an insane mother, which taught me a lot, and then running away only to join up with, are you ready for this, a totally mind-bending and dangerous cult. I managed to escape after only a couple of years, which wasn’t easy, and start again from scratch, and…
The lady in next row back speaks up, asks which cult are we talking about here, the Branch Dividians?
“No, no. It is Scientology, Not that it is anything, really, other that something you can fall for… We all need something to believe in. These guys give you all the good reasons to believe in them, then cut you off from the outside world, much like snapping fingers, conning you into believing that Scientology is a special science that nobody else knows, and also that it is a religion, although they never did quite get around to talking about God, whatever he has to say about this forsaken church is all still quite the mystery.”
I was getting quite the kick out of myself, telling my story, when finally I pause and Dave finally kicks in and, much to my surprise and very much to his credit, reveals to me that he, himself IS a scientologist…
My initial reaction to that tidbit of information was disbelief, and bypassing the mild shock, I say so.
“No, you’re not.
You can’t be. Scientologists do not ride buses around willy-nilly, as if they had places of their own to go to, they only go where they are TOLD to go, and it looks to me as if you are on your own. You must mean that you are an “Independent” scn-gist.
“Yes, that’s right.”, he said, “and, yes, I am on my own.”
…
It was in 2013, when I first ran into this site, and Chris Shelton introduces me to the phrase, “cognitive dissonance”. That’s one you won’t find in the Scientology dictionary,”critical thinking”, another notable deletion from that (no longer printed) “work”, if you have the generosity to call it that.
But Chris gave me the tools and vocabulary I so much needed to explain to myself how the heck I got caught in the trap, why was it so hard to break away from it and… Well,,, what the hell happened, really?
Turns out, that these questions are all vital to our survival as independent thinkers, and it has everything to do with what you believe in. It is after all, your choice.
My early advice, whoever I’m talking to, is to be very careful about what you choose to believe, because once you adopt a belief your natural human inclination would be to cling to that belief with all the determination that you may possess, rejecting any information that might conflict with that belief, thus leaving you rather trapped in an illusion, one that poses itself as reality, leaving you as the last one to know. The only safeguard you have from falling into such a trap is… REASON. This weapon of defense is worthless if you don’t use it. And the best way to employ reason is to ask questions.
Make sure your beliefs stand up to reason, and never stop searching for the next question to bolster your certainty. Doubt is a heathy thing, If your belief forbids doubt, hello, you are being conned because in this Universe there is no such thing as absolute, or “priveledged” knowledge. Whatever you believe, question it. Keep questioning, and you are sure to be ok…
…
At long last, my moment has arrived.
Since that day in 2013, I have had this fantasy of being the guy to frog-man my way onto the Appolo and rescue an oppressed Sea Org sailor, malnourished and starving for freedom, give him access to my life-raft tied to the side and together will we paddle our way back to shore, where I will reunite you with your loved ones…
You know, in this life, it is all about what you believe.
Choose carefully,
And keep reason close to your heart.
Tell the truth, be yourself and you will be ok.
Dave became anxious to get off the bus, did not care to share his last name. I was impressed nonetheless , that he revealed anything at all, to an independent thinker such as I, I had to be a rather threatening experience – for a believer such as he.
I gave it my best shot, and recommended the book, “The Bare-Faced Messiah” (out of print), he quite frankly promised never to read it. Was too enthused to talk about engrams and past lives, by golly, and the benefits of studying “Ethics”.
I hit him between the eyes, asking, “What’s the difference, please tell, between a ‘past-life recollectio’, and some thing of pure mental fabrication, and wouldn’t it be a good idea to keep those two concepts well sorted out, you know, in order to keep a grasp on what is, and is not, reality?”
But, I was obviously getting nowhere. I could tell Dave was happy to get off the bus, his stop could not have arrived soon enough. The ability to confront cognitive dissonance, no, that’s not the top topic for one comfortably burroughed in his beliefs.
…
“What Do You Say, To a Naked Scientologist?”,
…should be the title of my next book.
Mark – thank you for sharing that. Your story is powerful and it shouldn’t go unnoticed. Two things popped in my head while reading it. One was Dan Savage’s It Gets Better website/ campaign, and Steven Spielberg’s project to write down the names and stories of every person in the Holocaust. You can always start your own website or book – like what Chris did – to help survivors like yourselves. Even better – to educate those who may not know but can and want to help! Every story should be told. Thank you for sharing yours. It will help many people who read it to heal.
You are inspiring me to get on with my own book.
thank you